Icon512

Examining the Evidence

A belief can feel true simply because it produces a strong emotion.

Reframing Exercise

Examining the Evidence

A belief can feel true simply because it produces a strong emotion.

Bookmark
About This Practice

A belief can feel true simply because it produces a strong emotion. The feeling arrives first, and the mind treats its force as confirmation. This practice slows that down and asks what the actual evidence supports, looking at the evidence for the belief and the evidence against it with equal care. What you are after at the end is the most balanced and accurate belief available, not the most positive one.

In this exercise you will state the belief plainly, in one clear sentence. You will notice where you feel it in your body, observing the emotion and sensations without using their intensity as proof. Then you will ask what actual evidence supports the belief, keeping to facts you can verify rather than fears or predictions, and separating direct evidence from interpretation. Next you will ask what evidence contradicts the belief or shows that it is not completely true, and look there just as carefully, including exceptions, past outcomes, and facts the original belief may have filtered out. You will hold both sides together and notice which facts are strongest, what remains genuinely uncertain, and whether the belief claimed more than the evidence supports. Then you will state a more balanced and accurate belief, one that still includes the difficulty, and notice how your body responds as you say it.

Guided Practice

Choose the practice length that suits you today.

Ways to Practise

Meditation

Meditation

Sit or lie down comfortably, with your eyes closed or resting softly. Follow along with the audio recording.

Writing

Writing

Write one distressing belief as a clear statement. Record the emotion and body sensations connected with it. Do not use the intensity of the feeling as evidence that the belief is true. List the actual facts that support the belief. Include only events, words, actions, or other information you can verify. List the actual facts that contradict the belief or show that it is not completely true. Examine this side as carefully as the first. Review both lists. Write the most balanced and accurate belief the full evidence supports. Do not aim for the most positive version.

Inner Child

Inner Child

There is no inner child version for this practice.

Mirror

Mirror

Sit or stand where you can see your reflection. Use a soft gaze. State one distressing belief aloud. Notice the emotion and body sensations connected with it. State the facts that support the belief. Keep feelings and fears separate from evidence. State the facts that contradict it or show that it is not completely true. Look at yourself and state the most balanced and accurate belief supported by both sides. Notice how your body responds to the balanced belief.

Real-World Practice

Use this when a distressing belief is shaping your reaction and you have enough attention to pause. State the belief and separate the feeling from the facts. Ask what actual evidence supports it. Ask what actual evidence contradicts it or limits how completely true it is. Form the most accurate conclusion supported by both sides.

Micro Practice: Just three breaths…

  1. Breath – State the belief and the facts supporting it.
  2. Breath – Include the facts that contradict or limit it.
  3. Breath – State the most accurate balanced belief.

Practicing consistently is the key to mastering new skills.